MONA DANIELLA
  • Home
  • Comments
  • About
    • About 2
    • About 3
  • Celebrating Mona
    • Remembering
    • Videos
    • Memorial
    • Image Gallery
    • Family
    • Special Tributes
  • Eternal Light
  • True Kindness
  • Gifted and Talented
    • Awards
    • Writings
    • girls write now
    • Chorus
    • Mount Holyoke
  • Elephants
  • Mind-Brain Illnesses
    • Mind-Brain Illnesses 1
    • Mind-Brain Illness 2
    • Mind-Brain Illness 3
    • Mind-Brain Illness 4
    • Mind-Brain Illness 5
  • Blog

January 05th, 2025

1/5/2025

0 Comments

 
In a few days it will be Mona’s birthday. She would have been 35. She would have had kids. We would have Mona’s future. Instead I grieve her absence painfully.

All I have been asking is for an open, honest and thorough review in court to take place so that vital lessons could be learnt from Mona Daniella’s death.
I have a personal moral duty and obligation to act on the harmful SMS, email exchanges between the doctors and Mona Daniella; their negligence and malpractice and to make them public. 

I want to help prevent what happened to Mona Daniella from happening to other young people, to give them the best chances of survival, to be able to continue to live their lives, to contribute to society, to love and be loved, as Mona Daniella very much was. To prevent other parents from going through what we have been going through.

For the doctors who provided Mona a harmful treatment to try to silence me with a defamation lawsuit is nothing short of bullying.
If they believe they did nothing wrong, they should have nothing to fear and should not try to silence people. Carlene MacMillan alleged in court papers having PTSD from “my” posts (posts from their own texts) but yet she has no PTSD from alleged domestic violence from her husband Owen Scott Muir? 

I have PTSD from not only losing my only daughter, but worse even, losing her to suicide. Mona was constantly threatened up until the last phone calls of her life by Owen Scott Muir, and MacMillan did nothing to stop him. I have anxiety too. I might as well let the courts know.

Not only they harmed my daughter but now play the victim, by turning things around, and by lying. Shame on them. Other people have defamed them (I have not), yet they did not sue them. Why not?

They fleeced us when treating Mona. They were sued by many entities for non payment of debts. Now they are trying to get money from Mona even after her death through her parents.
What kind of people would do this?
Where is justice?

Disheartening is not the word. #justice4mona #grief#bereavedparents  #childloss
Picture
Dr Carlene MacMillan and Dr Owen Scott Muir suing me for Defamation in Retaliation Ito the Negligence and Malpractice case against them is nothing short of bullying. They want to silence my late daughter Mona Daniella. To silence their harmful treatment
0 Comments

NEW BOMBSHELL ALLEGATIONS ABOUT DR CARLENE MACMILLAN, DR OWEN SCOTT MUIR (3RD NAME CHANGE IN AROUND A YEAR). ALLEGED VIOLENT SEX WITH PATIENTS, ALLEGED HIPAA LAWS VIOLATIONS

1/30/2023

0 Comments

 
We continue to receive texts and emails from alleged former patients , and alleged former employees of Dr Carlene MacMillan and Dr Owen Scott Muir (his 3rd name change in around a year).

​This month is particularly hard because on January 11 it was Mona Daniella's birthday, she would have been 33 had she been alive.

The allegations are SHOCKING..
Dr Owen Scott Muir allegedly had sex with patients, and allegedly sent them pictures of people he tied up while having BDSM sex. Further he allegedly told a patient he met his wife at a BDSM party.
All the while allegedly his wife Dr Carlene MacMillan knows of her husband allegedly having sex with patients. Former employees allege she has 3 boyfriends. One former patient confirms this allegation. How would a patient know so much about the private lives of their therapists if they had not told them? We know they wrote plenty about their private lives (to the shopping tastes, swimming lessons for their twins, cars they like etc) to our late daughter. It would not shock us but it would surprise us if they allegedly continue the same pattern of behavior. That might show how callous they might allegedly be, and how they might allegedly believe they might be above rules and laws.

We live in America. This is a free country. We have no prejudice. 
This couple (MacMillan and Muir) are free to do whatever they want with their lives. They want an open marriage?
It is their right.
It is not their right to harm patients. They harmed our daughter in every possible way..
It becomes a huge problem when they demolish boundaries like they did with our daughter, and like they allegedly did with other patients.

It is a HIPAA LAWS VIOLATION to speak about patients to other people. 
Allegedly Dr Owen Scott Muir told patients about the patients who completed suicides. I go to a therapist. My therapist has never mentioned a word about any of her patients. We have met with a great number of therapists, forensic psychiatrists. None of them ever mentioned a single thing about their patients.

As to the alleged number of suicides - we have received texts that show allegedly  Muir talking of 10 or more suicides in a period of around 2 years. 
Many therapists have told us this is excessive. 

This makes us think they might allegedly be DOCTORS OF DEATH, not therapists one might go to heal. One patient wrote they almost took their own life.

TEXTS BELOW ARE FROM DIFFERENT PATIENTS
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
0 Comments

NEW BOMBSHELL ALLEGATIONS AGAINST DR. OWEN MUIR, AKA DR. SCOTT MUIR from brooklyn minds psychiatry - Re A Puppy

8/30/2022

0 Comments

 

Please read the bombshell allegations below, which are self explanatory, and if true, really, really scary.

Picture
0 Comments

Dr. Carlene MacMillan is proud osmind raised $40 million - why would Osmind Associate themselves with her? "Even with a public lawsuit against them a google search away"? (quotes by RH)

8/24/2022

0 Comments

 
We are shocked and concerned that companies continue to associate themselves with 
​
Dr. Carlene MacMillan, Dr. Owen Muir, aka, Dr. Scott Muir "even with a public lawsuit against them a google search away.". (quote by RH).
Not just any lawsuit: A Malpractice Lawsuit, an OPMC Investigation, and HIPAA LAWS VIOLATIONS by them maliciously, knowingly and willingly. 

Dr. Owen Muir, aka, Dr. Scott Muir. It is also "concerning given the examples of Dr. Carlene MacMillan, Dr. Owen Muir, aka, Dr. Scott Muir misusing digital tools in our complaint" (quote by RH) in court.

This is a classic case of "abuse by people in power" (such as therapists, etc) [quotes by RH)

Osmind.org just raised $40 million dollars. Why would they associate themselves with Dr. Carlene MacMillan, a self confessed Borderline, unstable psychiatrist who enabled her husband to allegedly rape our daughter, who enabled her husband to hurt and harm our daughter (it is all in SMS exchanges)?  Dr. Carlene MacMillan texted our daughter she had been diagnosed with Borderline Personality Disorder, she had affairs while married, all the while charging us handsomely.
Picture
WHY WOULD OSMIND ASSOCIATE THEMSELVES WITH HER? "EVEN WITH A PUBLIC LAWSUIT AGAINST THEM A GOOGLE SEARCH AWAY"? (QUOTES BY RH)
Picture
WHY WOULD OSMIND ASSOCIATE THEMSELVES WITH HER? "EVEN WITH A PUBLIC LAWSUIT AGAINST THEM A GOOGLE SEARCH AWAY"? (QUOTES BY RH)
0 Comments

Drs. Carlene MacMillan and Owen Muir aka Scott Muir allegedly have many Aliases... WHY?

8/17/2022

0 Comments

 
The following screenshots from Public records show that Drs. Carlene MacMillan and Owen Muir aka Scott Muir aka allegedly have many ALIASES - Allegedly Owen Muir has Owen Mary? If that is the case it brings the following question: WHY? WHY WOULD ANYONE HAVE SO MANY ALIASES?
Picture
Picture
0 Comments

Dr. Carlene MacMillan, Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir have removed their names from their company's website

8/17/2022

0 Comments

 
It could not get any more bizarre. Drs. Carlene MacMillan, Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir have removed their biographies from their company's website: Brooklyn Minds Psychiatry - https://brooklynminds.com/our-team/. Previously Dr. Carlene MacMillan and Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir were the 1st and 2nd in that order when you clicked our team. It is interesting to note that they removed their biographies around the time they posted our late daughter Mona Daniella's complete medical file on her website a DELIBERATE and BLATANT VIOLATION of HIPAA LAWS. 

​Please note that their names are still in the About Us page on the Brooklyn Minds Psychiatry Website.

​WHY WOULD THEY DO THAT?

As an aside, their company seems to have 
shrieked: previously they had over 52 people in their team. Now there are 17 people. 
Picture
Picture
0 Comments

DR. OWEN MUIR AKA DR. SCOTT MUIR REGISTERED TO VOTE TWICE ACCORDING TO PUBLIC RECORDS

8/17/2022

0 Comments

 
Dr Owen S Muir, aka Dr. Scott Muir might allegedly be a crook in addition to an alleged rapist: he registered to vote twice under different addresses according to public records. I guess it might allegedly be in him and of him. It’s illegal to vote twice, why would he register under 2 different addresses twice? More importantly why might Dr Owen Muir aka Dr Scott Muir allegedly feel entitled to vote more than other law abiding citizens? #mona#justice #malpractice #drcarlenemacmillan#drcarlenemac #drowenmuir#owen_muir_md #scottmuirmd #bklynminds#brooklynminds #harmful #treatment#manipulation #terror #noboundaries #vote#illegal #entitled #law
Picture
I believe it might be a felony to vote twice.  Allegedly Dr Owen Muir aka Dr Scott Muir might be shameless.

COMMENTS FROM PEOPLE WHO SAW THIS:

- 
Incredibly dishonest, true to his character.
- 😱 he thinks he's absolutely above any law!! 
-Both on the same date as well!
0 Comments

BOMBSHELL ALLEGATIONS FROM A PERSON WHOSE LIFE WAS ALLEGEDLY RUINED BY DR. OWEN MUIR AKA DR. SCOTT MUIR

8/17/2022

0 Comments

 
The following is a screenshot of a comment that was sent. Due to its allegations we decided not to post it in comments - instead we are posting the allegations of the screenshot in the blog.
Picture
0 Comments

MORE LIES FROM DR. OWEN MUIR AKA DR. SCOTT MUIR ... WHICH IS IT?

8/3/2022

0 Comments

 
On the posted comments of Mona Daniella's Medical File - Dr. Carlene MacMillan and Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir wrote in their reply to the OPMC  "In the end, the medical decisions that led to Mona Haddad’s completed suicide were not even made by me- the last attending of record was in the NYU emergency department,"

Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir lies shamelessly. On September 26, 2016, Dr. Carlene MacMillan and Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir kept hounding us Alan (Mona's dad) and myself (Mona's mom) to put them in touch with the Medical Examiner's office. We were naive and trusted them at that point. We had no idea they were the monsters who demolished our daughter. Alan called a politician from the community ( I texted her, please read the screenshot below from the person  who was able to connect Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir to the Medical Examiner's Office. Dr. Owen Muir told them (it is on record in the official report) that he was the doctor who saw Mona in NYU, and he discharged her.

Forensics have told us it is highly unusual, they have never heard of psychiatrists calling parents who just lost their child to help them get in touch with the medical examiner. Yet this is exactly what Dr. Carlene MacMillan and Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir did. Why would they do that? Not only they trashed Mona (which we found out later) but added more lies about me - Mona's mom.

Which is it? This is not the first lie, the first contradiction by Dr. Carlene MacMillan and Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir.

We willl be sending the screenshot, and the medical examiner's report where Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir told the Medical Examiner's Office that he was the doctor who saw Mona in NYU, and he discharged her.

NOW THEY ARE LYING TO THE OPMC. WHY ARE WE NOT SURPRISED?
Picture
0 Comments

PLEASE DO NOT SIGN "MONA HADDAD" WHEN LEAVING A COMMENT. IT WILL BE REMOVED.

7/24/2022

0 Comments

 
DR. CARLENE MACMILLAN, DR. OWEN MUIR, AKA DR. SCOTT MUIR FROM BROOKLYN MINDS PSYCHIATRY HAVE BEEN DOING THAT.
0 Comments

Dr. Carlene MacMillan, Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir from brooklyn minds psychiatry - kink and polyamory aware professionals who blatantly violate hipaa laws

7/24/2022

0 Comments

 

Dr. Carlene MacMillan, Dr. Owen Muir, aka Dr. Scott Muir, who keeps changing titles and now names from Brooklyn Minds Psychiatry are now Kink Aware Professionals [The Kink and Polyamory Aware Professionals Directory (KAP)] whatever that might mean.

​Alan and I repeat: these alleged perverts are free to sleep with whomever they want, but not rape our daughter and then push her to the edge - when she hanged herself after being threatened constantly by Dr. Owen Muir, aka Dr. Scott Muir, while his wife Dr. Carlene Muir did nothing to stop him. Posting on our daughter's website her medical file was a massive HIPAA Laws Violation.

Picture
Picture
0 Comments

Dr. Carlene MacMillan, Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir Blatant HIPAA LAWS VIOLATION, in addition to ignoring the "Goldwater Rule" from the American Psychiatry Association.

7/24/2022

0 Comments

 

Dr. Carlene MacMillan and Dr. Owen Muir, aka Dr. Scott Muir, aka other names from Brooklyn Minds Psychiatry, apparently might have skipped more psychiatry classes, this time on ethics - which regards the 'Goldwater Rule' from The American Psychiatry Association. [Excerpt of the Text of APA's Ethics Annotation Known as 'Goldwater Rule' ...it is unethical for a psychiatrist to offer a professional opinion unless he or she has conducted an examination and has been granted proper authorization for such a statement. ] 

For the record: Dr. Carlene MacMillan and Dr. Owen Muir, aka Dr. Scott Muir, aka other names from Brooklyn Minds Psychiatry, have never met me (Esther Haddad, the mother of Mona Daniella) in their offices. Neither have they ever examined me anywhere. On the contrary, they did everything they could to persuade Mona to avoid having a meeting. They succeeded - yet they had no shame to charge the tens of thousands of dollars a month they did.  McLean Hospital did not want to hire Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir. Dr. Carlene MacMillan resented Dr. Joe Gold for her husband not being hired by McLean Hospital and had told us she would never go back to McLean Hospital because of that. 

In that long tirade, filled with their filthy lies, they wrote about me (Esther Haddad, the mother of Mona Daniella) as "unwell" - this shows their blatant disregard or ignorance of the Goldwater Rule of the American Psychiatry Association. Dr. Carlene MacMillan and Dr. Owen Muir, aka Dr. Scott Muir, aka other names from Brooklyn Minds Psychiatry, also wrote in their post that I (Esther Haddad, the mother of Mona Daniella) "distorted" facts. Interesting. Especially since I have been posting texts they have themselves written to Mona Daniella. ​How else to explain them posting a long tirade of Mona Daniella's medical file in this website's Comments Section in blatant HIPAA LAWS VIOLATION in addition to their unethical and ignorant allegations about me?
​

Next: Dr. Carlene MacMillan and Dr. Owen Muir, aka Dr. Scott Muir, aka other names from Brooklyn Minds Psychiatry, it is not which one - alleged in that long tirade that they were one of the many treaters and saw Mona Daniella only once a week. We are puzzled by the tens of thousands of dollars they charged us each month. Perhaps their employees' allegations that Carlene MacMillan and Dr. Owen Muir, aka Dr. Scott Muir, aka other names from Brooklyn Minds Psychiatry, double charged more patients might be actual? How else to explain the excessive amounts charged to our credit cards for "one weekly visit"?
All this is in addition to the allegations of the NYU whistleblower about Dr. Owen Muir, aka Dr. Scott Muir, aka other names. 

Reminder of the 
Whistleblower Allegations:


"Please note that while Dr. Muir was treating patients in his private practice from 2015 and 2017. he was still a trainee at the NYU child and adolescent psychiatry program. In 2016 and 2017 he argued that he was disabled due to his psychiatric and physical conditions and that he should not be expected to treat psychiatric patients in the emergency room. Dr. Muir threatened NYU with a lawsuit for discrimination against people with disabilities if he were to be asked to complete his psychiatric emergency room rotation.

Hence. he managed to graduate from the program without having proper training and supervised experience working with patients suffering from psychiatric emergencies. which include suicidal behavior. On the one hand. he argued that he could not work with patients in crisis in a supervised setting and on the other he was seeing patients in crisis in his private practice. Either Dr. Muir lied to NYU in order to work less or he was seeing patients in private practice when he knew he was not emotionally and physically able to do so. In any case. it reflects poorly in Dr. Muir's character."
  

0 Comments

Dr. Owen Muir | Dr. Scott Muir changes his title every few months, AND ALLEGEDLY LIES, HIDES FACTS ABOUT THEM...

9/16/2020

1 Comment

 
Dr. Owen Muir keeps changing his title every few months, we have never seen anything like this. Around 5 months ago he was the Chief Service Officer, now he is the Chief Innovation Officer. Before that some other Chief Medical Officer and C0-Founder. Interesting enough, since the lawsuit started he is no longer listed as co-founder in the "Our Team" page, but when you go to the "learn more" page he is listed as Co-Founder. Actually, as far as we were told he was THE founder.
In LinkedIn he lies shamelessly: Chief Innovation Officer for 4 years and 1 month. He definitely wasn't in his web site which is updated constantly. What other lies is Dr. Owen Muir presumably telling?. 

Dr. Muir alleges to have the following Trainings and Certifications:
  • MBT: Supervisor Level
  • Ambit: Trainer
  • Completed additional training in MBT-A, MBT-F, MBT-C 
  • GPM: Trainer

Since the whistleblower alleged that Dr. Owen Muir did not complete his training in the Emergency Room as all other residents did - allegedly he threatened to sue NYU alleging his disability, we can't help but wonder - is Dr. Owen Muir really trained and certified completely in all the fields he alleges to be trained in?
Picture
This picture was taken on 4/30/2020, less than 5 months ago Dr. Owen Muir was Chief Services Officer
Picture
This picture was taken on September 16, 2020 - 4 1/2 month or less after claiming two be Chief Services Officer on their official website, Dr. Muir erased it from his history.
Picture
Picture taken on September 16, 2020, where Dr. Owen Muir allegedly lies shamelessly about having been Chief Innovation Officer Since September 2016. He wasn't.
Picture
Email from Dr. Owen Muir dated October 3, 2016. He alleges to be Clinical Instructor, NYU School of Medicine Assistant Professor of Medicine, Hofstra-Northwell School of Medicine. However, nowhere does that come up in his web site or in the LinkedIn Experience. Which makes us wonder - might have Dr. Muir presumably been lying to us about what he might not have been?
1 Comment

Dr. Owen Muir | Dr. Scott muir "Loving Mona is like washing the dead"... - ? - Anyone who read his email has told us this is so creepy.

1/19/2020

0 Comments

 

​An excerpt from an email from Dr. Owen Muir, of Brooklyn Minds, BklynMinds husband and partner of Dr. Carlene MacMillan: 

"Loving Mona was often like washing the dead...and yet those who do thankless things often are the most blessed, as I was watching Mona smile, succeed, and love...and eventually a witness to her burial." 

We are trying to understand: Did Dr. Owen Muir consider himself blessed for witnessing Mona's burial? And loving Mona was like washing the dead? Anyone we have shown his email has told us this is so creepy.

0 Comments

Reply from former Amherst student who was allegedly raped by Dr. Owen Muir, aka,  Dr. Scott muir to "oh's" comment (Of Note: 3 women are ALLEGing Dr. Owen Muir raped or sexually assaulted them)

12/6/2019

0 Comments

 

Former Amherst  said:
Esther informed me they received a comment claiming this is made up. Well, it isn't. Would you like more details? I remember going to see Owen's band play around the same time; I think they were called the Magnets, and I'm pretty sure they were playing at the Zu. We also hung out at Marsh (where Owen lived) and the Hungry Newt for a bit. Mutual friends have heard the story. I am not some angry ex-employee, though I'm not surprised that people close to him have to believe that. I am a woman that he raped.

Of note: SO FAR 3 WOMEN ARE ALLEGING DR. OWEN MUIR RAPED OR SEXUALLY ASSAULTED THEM. 
0 Comments

Bombshell RAPE ALLEGATION AGAINST DR. OWEN MUIR, aka, Dr. Scott Muir FROM A FORMER AMHERST STUDENT

11/30/2019

2 Comments

 

FORMER AMHERST STUDENT
11/29/2019 11:54:33 PM This is hard for me to talk about, but I think it's important that I say something. 

I knew Owen Muir when we were both students at Amherst College. He raped me. I was around 17 at the time and drunk, and he was an upperclassman and a new friend; I'd told him about how I had been sexually abused as a child, and I thought he was so caring and understanding. We were talking and lying on my bed in my dorm when he started removing my clothes. It was so sudden that, at first, I actually thought he was undressing me so I could go to sleep; by the time I figured out what he was doing, I was frozen and couldn't move. I trusted him and he attacked me. 

It had a deeply devastating effect on my life and on my college career. Since then, I have been told about other victims of his as well. I have often considered reporting what he did to me, but I can't prove what happened (campus rape is rarely prosecuted), and Owen is so litigious and vindictive that I'm terrified of going up against him. I don't want him to come after me. 

I was very concerned even in college that he studied psychology and intended to become a doctor. I have worried for years that young women and girls are not safe with him. When I read about what happened to Mona, I was disturbed and appalled, and my fears were confirmed. I hope you are able to hold him accountable at long last. He is dangerous and I want him to stop hurting vulnerable people.

2 Comments

Re allegations From a Whistleblower about Dr. Owen Muir, aka, Dr. Scott muir and NYU Langone Medical Center

11/29/2019

0 Comments

 

From Alan (Mona Daniella's father):
A whistleblower from NYU who wrote to us is further proof that Dr. Owen Muir did not have the capacity to treat Mona Daniella.

Only a whistleblower can provide such precise information.
The message was written by either a doctor or an attorney: it is very well written, by an educated person, who is very familiar with the specifics of psychiatric Emergency Room procedures, in addition to being quite familiar with Muir's graduation history.

Should the whistleblower's bombshell allegations prove to be true, it would clearly show NYU Langone Medical Center should have never allowed Dr. Owen Muir to graduate, then to be involved with, to consult, or to give any advice whatsoever to the Emergency Room psychiatric staff precisely because he had never gotten "
the proper training and supervised experience working with patients suffering from psychiatric emergencies, which include suicidal behavior". This would mean that NYU Langone Medical Center allegedly knowingly and willingly allowed Dr. Owen Muir to encourage the Emergency Room to discharge Mona, or at worse the Psychiatric Emergency Room staff discharged Mona without having been told by NYU Langone Medical Center that Dr. Owen Muir is not allegedly qualified to take care of patients in crisis. 
Either way the whistleblower's allegation is damning: allegedly NYU Langone Medical Center knowingly and willingly aided and abetted Dr. Owen Muir first by allowing him to graduate without the required training, second by allowing him to work around with patients suffering from psychiatric emergencies, which include suicidal behavior - despite knowing he lacked the qualifications, and the experience; and allegedly NYU Langone Medical Center knowingly and willingly chose to not take any precautions whatsoever to safeguard the lives of their patients by in all probability choosing earnings ahead of lives.
​The whistleblower's allegation makes it more difficult to understand why NYU Langone Medical Center would give hospital privileges to Dr. Owen Muir especially since he had allegedly threatened to sue them. Getting hospital privileges is difficult in New York City.

This is exactly what Dr. Owen Muir did to our daughter Mona Daniella - in regards to her treatment, (without our knowledge of the whistleblower's allegations),  We have thousands of SMS text exchanges between Dr. Owen Muir and Mona Daniella  and Dr. Carlene MacMillan and Mona Daniella to support this. He called the police on her (then lied about it) - actually worse, he asked Dr. Carlene MacMillan to call the police on Mona Daniella and had her taken to Bellevue hospital on trumped up charges despite knowing Bellevue was her biggest fear. In addition Dr. Owen Muir threatened Mona Daniella multiple times. Dr. Carlene MacMillan was aware because Mona Daniella texted her numerous times about the threats, yet did nothing about it. Talk about conflict of interest (this is one amongst many)..

This allegation  doesn't simply reflect poorly on Dr. Owen Muir's character. The allegation would mean Dr. Owen Muir is fraudulent - akin to crooks who operate Ponzi schemes; they profess to do something that in reality they neither have the capability, nor are ever able to deliver the expected or promised results.

The whistleblower's allegations only help us believe further more how NYU Langone Medical Center was negligent and in all probability money meant all to them for them to neglect our late daughter Mona Daniella.

Dr. Owen Muir did not have the capacity to treat Mona Daniella - we now see this not just from the SMS text exchanges which is horrific. As a consequence he would never be able to deliver the expected results. And in fact he did not.

Dr. Owen Muir and Dr. Carlene Macmillan had an ethical obligation to advise us Dr, Owen Muir was not even a trainee before he started treating Mona Daniella. Instead they led us to believe he was an excellent psychiatrist (yes excellent at shouting, excellent at threatening, excellent at lying to the police by saying our daughter. had assaulted him while the SMS texts show this was clearly not the case). Had we known how Dr. Owen Muir and Dr. Carlene MacMillan were incompetent, unprofessional, unethical, negligent, liars and much more we would have never, never, never allowed Mona Daniella to be treated by them. Especially to start with Dr. Carlene MacMillan who knew first hand all the horrors Mona Daniella had gone through while misdiagnosed this treated with the wrong treatment - at the hands of doctors (Dr. Carlene MacMillan told us they were "green" not experienced doctors) in McLean Hospital, Belmont, Massachusetts where she had worked before (and did not hire her husband Dr. Owen Muir by their own admission).

This is definitely Pure Malpractice and Pure Negligence by all defendants in the lawsuit - the  malpractice and negligence were not simple negligence; they were knowingly and willingly.

0 Comments

A WHISTLEBLOWER's ALLEGATIONS ABOUT DR. OWEN MUIR, aka, Dr. Scott Muir and NYU Langone Medical Center

11/29/2019

0 Comments

 

Bombshell new allegations against Dr. Owen Muir, aka, Dr. Scott Muir!
Thank you Whistleblower.

These allegations needs to be investigated! 
If they are proven to be true - Dr. Owen Muir, aka, Dr. Scott Muir needs to be held accountable for much more than we initially thought - also regardless if true or not shame on his wife Dr. Carlene MacMillan who knowingly and willingly aided and abetted her sick and disturbed husband Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir to threaten our late daughter Mona Daniella. He called the police on her on made up charges. Dr. Carlene MacMillan knows her husband is sick - there are multiple SMS exchanges that show the above. Dr. Carlene MacMillan needs to be hold accountable as well. 

Thank you again Whistleblower. We hope and welcome any further information.

Whistleblower - We also have a gift for you: In an email, while she was still working  for NYU Langone Medical Center, Dr. Carlene MacMillan, instructed Alan (Mona Daniella's father) and me to pay for her services through her husband / Dr. Owen Muir’s business Brooklyn Minds . We did not know that this is allegedly fraud. Apparently when doctors work for a hospital the hospital takes a share of the fees they charge patients. And doctors are not allowed to charge patients from other entities.

We have her email, the one with the above instructions that she sent to us. We believe NYU Langone Medical Center should investigate this.

0 Comments

WHISTLEBLOWER's BOMBSHELL ALLEGATIONS AGAINST DR. OWEN MUIR aka Dr. Scott Muir and NYU Langone Medical Center

11/29/2019

0 Comments

 

The allegations by a WHISTLEBLOWER submitted earlier today: 
11/28/2019 01:23:48 PM

"Please note that while Dr. Muir was treating patients in his private practice from 2015 and 2017, he was still a trainee at the NYU child and adolescent psychiatry program.
In 2016 and 2017 he argued that he was disabled due to his psychiatric and physical conditions and that he should not be expected to treat psychiatric patients in the emergency room.

Dr. Muir threatened NYU with a lawsuit for discrimination against people with disabilities if he were to be asked to complete his psychiatric emergency room rotation.
Hence, he managed to graduate from the program without having proper training and supervised experience working with patients suffering from psychiatric emergencies, which include suicidal behavior.

On the one hand, he argued that he could not work with patients in crisis in a supervised setting and on the other he was seeing patients in crisis in his private practice.

​Either Dr. Muir lied to NYU in order to work less or he was seeing patients in private practice when he knew he was not emotionally and physically able to do so. In any case, it reflects poorly in Dr. Muir’s character.”

0 Comments

reply To The Anonymous "friend's" comment from october 6, 2019

10/13/2019

0 Comments

 
A week ago, on October 06, 2019, an anonymous "friend" left the following comment:

"Mona would not have wanted you to do this. Mona cared deeply about Dr Muir and Dr. MacMillan. She would be heartbroken to see what you are trying to do. In your heart of hearts, you know that."

No, anonymous friend. In my heart of hearts I do not know that.
Neither do you. You have ABSOLUTELY NO IDEA about what went on. You have no idea about how Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir "lost it" (in Mona's own words). You have no idea about the needless and senseless suffering that Mona went through in their hands. If Mona cared deeply about Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir she would not have wanted to change psychiatrists. And she would not have left the negative review in Yelp.

​Take a look at the screenshot below from the SMS exchange between Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir and Mona. This is mild compared to other screenshots.

So no anonymous friend, Mona did not care deeply about Dr. MacMillan and Dr. Owen Muir aka Dr. Scott Muir. Reading about what really went on - classic malpractice and negligence - explains why on the same day that Mona was buried both Drs. MacMillan and Muir were so eager to get Mona's journals - to the point of telling her aunt "it was Mona's wishes that they (Drs. MacMillan and Muir) get her journals. It was not. In fact Mona wanted to publish them.  They wanted to destroy the evidence against them. if you read what's inside those SMS you would be horrified. In your heart of hearts. Dr. Muir "lost it" more than once. Dr. MacMillan did nothing about it - not once. The relationship was harmful. That's malpractice and negligence right there. Let the courts decide. Let the judge and jury read everything. And let them decide.

Go to Yelp reviews. Mona is not the only nor first case of negligence, and of malpractice. Please read the screenshot below - it's a review by a physician. That speaks volumes.

One last question: why are you anonymous? None of Mona's friends have been anonymous until now. Why won't you say who you are? 
Picture
Picture
0 Comments

MONA DANIELLA'S NEGATIVE YELP REVIEW OF DR. OWEN MUIR, aka, Dr. Scott Muir, LESS THAN A WEEK BEFORE HER sudden and tragic SUICIDE (MALPRACTICE LAWSUIT AGAINST DR. CARLENE MACMILLAN and Dr. owen muir, aka, Dr. Scott Muir, BROOKLYN MINDS PSYCHIATRY, NYU la

8/28/2019

0 Comments

 
Mona Daniella's NEGATIVE YELP review of Dr. Owen Muir - please note the 1st one is dated 9/18/2016, and the updated review is dated: 9/20/2016.
They are self explanatory. 
​
On 9/26/2016 Mona took her own life. Less than a week after her review.

For reasons unknown to us, although Mona's reviews do not seem to violate Yelp's guidelines, they are in the YELP's section of reviews that are not currently recommended.

YELP deleted my review.  Even though I followed their rules.

PictureMona Daniella's Negative YELP review of Dr. Owen Muir, from Brooklyn Minds
0 Comments

New York Post Article about the MALPRACTICE LAWSUIT AGAINST DR. CARLENE MACMILLAN, dr. OWEN MUIR, aka,  Dr. Scott Muir, BROOKLYN MINDS PSYCHIATRY, NYU langone medical centre AND SOME OF ITS EMPLOYEES

8/26/2019

0 Comments

 

UPDATE TO THE CASE

Picture


Here is the link to the New York Post article about the lawsuit:
 
Family of suicide victim sues psychiatrists for her death 

"SHRINKS RAPPED"
​

The article mentions "One of her own friends" - "Haddad’s friend, who asked not to be identified". 
​We know this friend and love her. We have reached out to her to let her know we love her, and she will always be welcome in our home. 
Another friend (both Mona Daniella's and this friend's) believes she might have been in all probability manipulated by Dr. Muir? 


It's a miracle the New York Post ran this story at all as someone who is an objective person mentioned. In the New York Post's story Drs. Carlene MacMillan and Owen Muir do not come across well no matter what. It's a large story, and starts with how both doctors inappropriately discussed their personal lives (it is actually beyond inappropriate).  We know that the New York Post had a couple of reporters working long hours on this story. We are grateful for the Post printing one of our favorite pictures of Mona Daniella, with EMMA her puppy, and for the reporter writing some of the quotes from the complaint.  

Mona Daniella will have her day in court, and both Drs. Carlene MacMillan and Owen Muir will have to face what they did to Mona.

​Here is the link to the complaint against for those who have not read it yet:

https://iapps.courts.state.ny.us/fbem/DocumentDisplayServlet?documentId=3WsUqISxtz0PYJ1KIciMrw%3D%3D&system=prod&fbclid=IwAR0_DG9eNa3V47d_JbNjkFRnw10OJgCMm2yymORjbHlgXii2-IGHsCnTapI


0 Comments

    REMEMBERING
    ​MONA DANIELLA

    Mona Daniella was a sensitive, gentle, kind, and caring person. She epitomized "Chessed", Loving-Kindness.
    ​
    She fought extremely hard. In a 2014 email I wrote to her that she was the bravest, the brightest, the most determined and the most resilient. Indeed she was. And much more.

    Archives

    January 2025
    November 2024
    September 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    January 2023
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    November 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    May 2021
    October 2020
    September 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    September 2018
    November 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016

    Categories

    All
    10 Suicides In Around 2 Years
    11 Months Prayers
    12 Months' Prayers
    1997
    1st Anniversary
    1st Wedding Anniversary Without Mona Daniella
    1 Week Before Roshashanah
    2000
    2010
    2012
    2014
    2015
    2016
    2017
    2018
    2019
    2020
    2021
    2022
    2023
    2024
    23 Elul
    2710 Days
    2nd Anniversary
    2nd Anniversary Since Mona Daniella Has Been Gone
    2 Years
    3
    34
    35th Birthday
    3rd Year Anniversary
    5 Years
    8
    8th Anniversary Of Death
    9/11
    Activism
    Actor
    Alan Haddad
    Aliases
    Allegation
    Allegation Dr. Owen Muir Killed Puppies
    Allegation Muir And MacMillan Abise Their Kids
    Allegations Owen Muir Is A Creep
    Alleged 6
    Alleged BDSM SEX With Patients
    Alleged HIPAA LAWS VIOLATIONS
    Amarilys Zimmerman
    American Association Of Suicidology
    American Foundation For Suicide Prevention
    Amherst Young Student
    Ana
    Angry Allegation
    Ariella Michal Medows
    Arrayat Mishmara
    Ateret Avraham Synagogue
    Attorney Mitev
    August
    August 2019
    Aunt Evelyne
    Aveilut
    Baby
    Beach
    Bela
    Bereaved Mother
    Bereavement
    BiPolar
    Bipolar Hypersexuality
    Birthday
    @BKLYNminds
    BOBMSHELL ALLEGATIONS
    Bombshell Allegations
    Boston
    Boundaries Are Demolished
    Broadway Show
    Brooklyn Minds
    Brooklyn Minds Psychiatry
    Brooklyn Minds Psychiatry Employee
    Brooklyn Minds Psychiatry Ex-employee
    Brooklyn Minds Psychistry
    Bunny Feet
    Caitlin Belforti
    Canada
    Candles Lit In Mona's Memory
    Carlene MacMillan
    Carlene MacMillan.eth MD
    Charter Communication
    Child Loss
    Childloss
    Citation
    Columbia University Oral History Project
    Comments From 2019
    Comments From Family
    Comments From Friends
    Comments Same IP Address
    Complaints
    Conflict Of Interest
    Congregation Beth Edmond
    Court
    Cousin Solita
    Crisis Text Line
    Curated Mental Health
    Daniel
    Daniella Tree
    December 2019
    Dedication
    Defamation
    Defamation Lawsuit
    Defamation Lawsuit In Retaliation
    Derelict Of Duty
    Different Names
    Drawing
    Dr Carlene MacMillan
    Dr. Carlene MacMillan
    Dr. Carlene MacMillan Allegedly Goes Along With Her Husband's Lies
    Dr. Carlene MacMillan's Lies
    Dr. O. Scott Muir
    Dr Owen Muir
    Dr. Owen Muir
    Dr. OWEN MUIR Aka Dr. Scott Muir
    Dr. Owen Muir Alleged Lies
    Dr Owen Muir ANGRY
    Dr Owen Scott Muir
    Dr Scott Muir
    DR. SCOTT MUIR
    Dr. Scott Muir
    Drs MacMillan And Muir Alleged Doctors Of Dearh
    Effects Of Suicide
    Elephants
    Elevation Of The Soul
    Email From A Friend
    Email To Friends When Mona Died
    Emma
    Emma Duffett
    Esther Haddad
    Esther Khafif Haddad
    Evil
    Excessive Charges
    Fake Emails
    Fall
    Fall 2017 Orientation Issue
    Family Of Suicide Victim Sues Psychiatrists For Her Death
    Family Picture
    Family Video
    February 2002
    February 2024
    Fermata Health
    Fishing
    FOLLOWER
    France
    Franny
    Friend
    Friends
    Friends' Comments
    Friendship
    Friend's Message
    Fun Fact
    Game Of Throne's Star
    G-D KNOWS WHAT YOU DID AND HE WILL IN DUE TIME BRING YOU TO JUSTICE
    Gone For 5 Months
    Grateful
    Grief
    Grieving Mother
    [email protected]
    Hamilton
    Harmful Treatment
    Harvard Law Record
    Have
    Help
    Help A Suicidal Person
    HIPAA LAWS VIOLATION
    Holiday
    Home
    Host Name Nyc.res-rr.com
    Hydrangeas
    Ilui Neshama
    In Memoriam
    In Memory
    In Memory Of Menuha Bat Ester
    In Mona's Honor
    Interview About Stigma
    Investigative Journalist
    IP Address 66.108.28.27
    Iphone
    Italy
    January
    January 11
    January 2024
    January 2025
    Jason Foundation
    Jasper E. Bliss
    Jennifer
    JQY Memorial In December
    Judaism
    Justice 4 Mona
    Justice For Mona
    Kaddish
    Kings County
    Kink And Polyamory Aware Professionals
    Kit Harington
    Kristen Carpenter
    Laptop
    Last 4 Phone Calls Of Mona's Life
    Last Email To Dr. Rebecca Berry
    Lauren Elizabeth
    Lawsuit
    Lawsuits
    Legal
    Liars
    Lies
    LOSS OF A CHILD
    Lost Promises
    Loving Mona Was Often Like Washing The Dead
    MA
    Mac Robert
    Malpractice
    Malpractice Against Brooklyn Minds
    Malpractice Against Dr. Carlene MacMillan
    Malpractice Against Dr. Owen Muir
    Malpractice Against Dr. Owen Scott Muir
    Malpractice Against Dr. Scott Muir
    Malpractice Against NYU And Staff
    Malpractice Lawsuit
    Malpractice Lawsuit Against Dr. Owen Muir Aka Dr. Scott Muir
    Manipulation
    March 2024
    Maria Elvira From Spain
    Mariel
    May 28
    McLean Hospital
    M.D
    Mental Disorder
    Mental Health
    Mental Illness
    Michal
    Mind Brain Illness
    Mind-Brain Illness
    Mishmara "Arayat"
    Miss Mona Haddad
    Miss You
    Mona Concerned
    Mona Daniella
    Mona Daniella 7 Years Old
    Mona Daniella And Her Puppy EMMA
    Mona Daniella Foundation
    Mona Daniella Haddad
    Mona Daniella's Bat-Mitzvah
    Mona Daniella's Birthday
    Mona Daniella's Suicide
    Mona Is Never Again
    Mona NEVER AGAIN
    Mona's Birthday
    Mona's Friend
    Mona's Friend Comment From IP 66.108.28.27
    Mona's Joournalks
    Mona's Maternal Great Grandmother
    Mona's Resting Place
    Mona's Tomb
    Mount Holyoke
    Mourning
    Mr. Mitev
    Muir Allegedly Abuses His Children
    Muir And MacMillan's Desperate Attempt To Get Mona's Journals
    Muir Threatened Mona Daniella
    My Personal Phone Number
    National Suicide Prevention Hotline
    National Suicide Prevention Lifeline
    Negligence
    Negligence And Malpractice
    Negligence And Malpractice Lawsuit
    Negligence Lawsuit
    New Allegations
    News Article
    New Year
    New York
    New York City
    New York Post
    New York Post Article
    No Invoices For Months
    November 2024
    Nyu
    NYU Langone Medical Centre
    October
    October 2019
    October 2020
    "Oh" Comment
    Oklahoma House Of Representatives
    One Year
    One Year Since Mona Has Left Us
    Osmind
    Osmind.org
    Other Alleged Victims As Well
    Owen Muir
    Owenmuir.com
    Owen Muir Not Qualified To Treat Mona
    Owen Scott Muir
    Prayer L'Eloui Nishmat Menuha Bat Ester
    Prayers
    Prayers In Australia
    Prayers In Brasil
    Prayers In New York
    Provincetown
    Psychiatrist
    Psychiatrists
    Public Information
    Punta Del Este
    Puppy
    Rape Allegation
    Rape Allegations Against Dr. Owen Muir From Brooklyn Minds
    Registered To Vote Twice
    Remarks On Suicide Awareness Month By Owen Muir
    Remembering Mona Daniella
    Remembrance Day 2024
    Representative James E. Hamilton
    Restorative Justice
    Retaliatory Lawsuit
    Reviews
    Rob Wipond
    Roshashana
    Roshashanah
    Same IP Address Comments
    Sephardic Traditions
    September 2016
    September 2019
    September 2020
    September 26
    Seudah Slisheet
    Shiva
    Shrink
    Shrinks
    Shrinks Rapped
    SMS Exchange Mona With Muir
    SMS Text Exchanges
    Snacks & Beverages Offered In Mona's Memory
    Society For The Prevention Of Teen Suicide
    Spain
    Speaker Lloyd Benson
    Spectrum
    #stonewallprotestors
    Substance Abuse And Mental Health Administration
    Suicidal Ideation
    Suicide
    Suicide Prevention Advocacy Network (SPAN)
    Suicide Prevention Online Chat
    @SulomeAnderson
    Sulome Anderson
    Support
    Supreme Court Of New York
    Temporary Restraint Order
    Terrorise
    Texts From Former Employees
    Texts From Former Patients
    @TheAtlantic
    The Day Muir Decides To Emulate His Father
    The Estate Of Mona Daniella Haddad Plaintiff
    The Post
    There Is Something Wrong With Him
    The State Of Oklahoma
    "The Wish Tree"
    Thousands And Thousands And Thousands Of Dollars
    Tiffany Wong
    Torture
    TRO
    True Kindness
    Twitter
    Twitter Posts
    Unethical
    Unicorn
    Unprofessional
    Upper East Side Synagogue
    URUGUAY
    "We Blame Ourselves!!"
    Whistleblower
    Winnicot
    Www.mitevlaw.com
    Www.raymitevlaw.com
    Yellow Ribbon Suicide Prevention Program
    Yelp
    Yelp Negative Review
    Your Consent Is Not Required

    RSS Feed

    SIGN UP
    YOUR EMAIL IS SAFE. NO 3RD PARTY SELLING

Submit
📞 +1.917.774.0333   |   📧  [email protected]
 Copyright © Estate of Mona Daniella Haddad 2016 - 2025. All rights reserved.
  • Home
  • Comments
  • About
    • About 2
    • About 3
  • Celebrating Mona
    • Remembering
    • Videos
    • Memorial
    • Image Gallery
    • Family
    • Special Tributes
  • Eternal Light
  • True Kindness
  • Gifted and Talented
    • Awards
    • Writings
    • girls write now
    • Chorus
    • Mount Holyoke
  • Elephants
  • Mind-Brain Illnesses
    • Mind-Brain Illnesses 1
    • Mind-Brain Illness 2
    • Mind-Brain Illness 3
    • Mind-Brain Illness 4
    • Mind-Brain Illness 5
  • Blog